See also Biology Department Guide to Graduate Studies: http://www.queensu.ca/biology/gradpostdoc/current/guide-2.html
Queen’s University School of Graduate Studies (SGS) web site : http://www.queensu.ca/sgs/home
the SGS FAQs site: http://www.queensu.ca/sgs/current-students/frequently-asked-questions
ABOUT SUPERVISORY COMMITTEES (SVCs)
Who is on my MSc supervisory committee (SVC)?
For an MSc student, the SVC consists of the Supervisor (and co-supervisor if applicable) and at least two other faculty members, one of whom must be a regular (i.e. not Cross-appointed or adjunct) faculty member in Biology, and one of whom is recommended to be from a different research area either inside or outside the department. You can have more folks on the SVC if you want.
Who is on my PhD supervisory committee?
For a PhD student, the SVC consists of the Supervisor (and co-supervisor if applicable) and at least two other faculty members, one of whom must be a regular (i.e. not Cross-appointed or adjunct) faculty member in Biology, and one of whom must be from a different research area either inside or outside the Department. In some circumstances a student may have a committee member who is not a member of the School of Graduate Studies, or may even be from outside Queen's. In such cases, a request must be made in writing to the Graduate Studies Committee, stating reasons for the request and qualifications of the proposed committee member. Again, there are no restrictions in adding more folks if you wish to but oversized SVCs can be cumbersome when trying to schedule meetings.
How often should I meet with my committee?
The SVC MUST meet at least once each year with the student. For this meeting the student should send a brief written summary of research progress (usually 2-5 pages) to the SVC at least five working days prior to the committee meeting. This summary should include a month-by-month plan for completion of the thesis. The supervisor will keep copies of these research summaries. It is the responsibility of the supervisor and student to ensure that these meetings take place. Students (or supervisors) should call a supervisory committee meeting any time there are academic problems or difficulties with the research program, or when a thesis defense or comprehensive exam is to be scheduled in the near future.
When should I hold my first committee meeting?
You should hold your first meeting within 6 months of enrolment in the graduate program.
What if someone from my SVC is on sabbatical?
These days, using skype or teleconferencing, it is usually still possible to hold meetings, even defense exams, when a committee member is out of town. Nevertheless, it is advised that students make arrangements with any members of their SVC regarding any deadlines or related issues if a SVC member is expected to be unavailable for an extended period.
What if I want to change the composition of my SVC committee partway through my program?
As long as the composition fulfills the requirements (see above), this is easy to do. Make sure that the graduate administrator is made (in writing) aware of the composition of the revised SVC
What if, due to personal conflicts, I want to change supervisors during my program?
Occasionally, situations arise where it may be in the student’s best interest to seek external advice/support about changing supervisors. This question is addressed on the SGS site: http://www.queensu.ca/sgs/current-students/frequently-asked-questions
How many hours am I expected to work for each TAship?
Does that 65 hours include preparation time, including attendance at lectures if the prof thinks I need to?
Each course instructor completes a TA-agreement form that indicates time-on-task and expectations. This form is signed by both the TA and the course instructor.
What do I do if it looks like I am going to do a little (or a lot) more (or less) than 65 hours?
TA commitments may vary a bit from the TA agreement as unexpected issues arise (e.g. equipment problems in labs, higher-than-expected student emails, etc.). It is important that TAs keep track of their hours and communicate with the course instructor if their hours are deviating by more than 10% (collectively) from the agreed upon plan. It’s a good idea to evaluate how much time you are spending at about the 6-week mark and inform the instructor or professor if you think you are doing more than you are being paid for. Please talk to the Graduate Studies Coordinator if you think you are doing too much work but do that early rather than when the course has finished.
ABOUT THESIS DEFENSES
When should I schedule my defense?
Before scheduling a defense, you should meet with your SVC and get their approval to submit and defend your thesis. Please indicate on the committee report form that your project is essentially completed and ready to be written up in the form of a thesis. Once your supervisor deems your thesis complete, you should then schedule your defense. It is always your right to submit your thesis at any time whether or not your supervisor and committee approve.
Who will be at my MSc defense?
You can choose and ‘open’ or ‘closed’ defense. For an open defence, an audience (eg. labmates, friends) is permitted to attend following your seminar presentation, but they are not free to ask questions. In a closed defense, only the examining committee is present. The MSc examining committee is comprised of a minimum of 5 faculty, as follows:
Either the Chair or the internal-external examiner must be from a different department
Who will be at my PhD defense?
See the note above for ‘MSc defense’. In addition, a PhD examination committee has an external examiner. This is an expert in your field from a different university (i.e. they cannot be Queen’s faculty). All committee members must be approved by the Exam Chair.
How long do I have to revise my thesis and submit my thesis after my defense if revisions are needed?
In the case of a successful defense but where thesis revision are required (very common), revisions should be done as quickly as possible and are expected to be completed and resubmitted within a week’s time. Officially, however, you have up to one year to submit revisions but you will be charged tuition until the final version is submitted.
How late can I defend in each term and avoid all tuition fees?
Usually the thesis must be defended and corrections submitted before the end of the first month in a term.
Can I submit my thesis as a PDF to my examiners?
Ask each of your examiners what they prefer.
Is there a maximum page length?
For an MSc thesis, 100 pages inclusive of everything but appendices and front matter (title page, tables of contents, etc.). For a PhD thesis, 175 pages inclusive of everything but appendices and front matter. If you wish to submit a thesis longer than these maxima, you must obtain written permission from each member of the supervisory committee before submission. See Section 13.3 in the Department Guide to Grad Studies (http://www.queensu.ca/biology/gradpostdoc/current/guide-2.html)
What are the formatting requirements?
There are two acceptable formats: (i) traditional thesis format or (ii) manuscript format. See section 13 in the Department Guide to Grad Studies for details (http://www.queensu.ca/biology/gradpostdoc/current/guide-2.html)
The School of Graduate Studies also has important information on thesis formatting to help you out: http://www.queensu.ca/sgs/thesis-formatting-other-resources
Do I have to include a general introduction and discussion?
Yes, even if you are using a manuscript format. Several pages of general discussion can be a useful forum to speculate, point to future directions, raise new questions, etc. It is a good place to present ideas that may fall outside the realm of what would be included in any manuscripts
Can my data chapters be in a format that I would submit to a journal for publication?
Yes, see the above notes on ‘manuscript format’ for theses. But keep in mind that you are still required to abide by the formatting regulations provided by the School of Grad Studies (see url link above for SGS format rules).
Can I use colour on my graphs?
Yes, but be sure to use high-contrast colours and avoid colours that may not be distinguishable to someone who is red-green colour-blind.
What are the formatting requirements for graphs?
You should use the format that is most commonly found in journal articles in your field of research.
Where should I put my figures?
Figures should be embedded in the results section(s) of your thesis. They must be numbered and each figure should be embedded at the point-of-1st-mention in the text describing that figure. The same rule applies for Tables. Extensive data tables (e.g. raw data) can be place in an appendix. Captions should be directly below a figure (or above a Table) wherever possible. When the image/table size prevents this, they should be on the facing page of the Table/Figure. Images and text within a figure must be legible so be sure to check this if you are using small fonts within your figures – use a minimum font size of 8.
What is the minimum guaranteed annual stipend?
This changes from year to year, usually in consideration of inflation. As of January 2014, the minimum stipend was $22,650/yr.
Where does this money come from?
The salary is a combination of funding from: TA-ships, QGAs (Queen’s Graduate Awards – generally guaranteed to every in-time student), supervisor’s research grant and, if available, internal or external scholarships. Students who have major scholarships are not be given first preference for TAing.
When do I get paid?
Typically, payment is monthly, on the last day of the month, in equal installments.
Can I earn more money if I want or need to?
Depending upon the availability of TAships, and/or supervisor’s willingness/ability to contribute additional funding, it may be possible to earn more than the minimum stipend.
How long do I get this stipend for?
The guaranteed stipend for full-time students covers 2-years for MSc and 4-years for PhD students, from time of first enrolment. After these periods, students are considered ‘overtime’ and continued funding is at the supervisor’s discretion.
Who pays for my books and supplies?
Stationary supplies should be provided by your supervisor. You will probably have to pay for additional texts, journal subscriptions (not found in Queen’s library system), or other related books.
Who pays for my research expenses?
Your supervisor will probably pay most of your expenses from their research grants but students often get (usually small) research grants on their own that will help to defray some of the costs.
How is the amount available for my research determined?
Supervisors are expected to anticipate and budget for all research-related expenses.
Who pays for me to go to conferences?
Funding for conference attendance is covered by research grants and a small amount is available each year from the Biology Department and/or the School of Graduate Studies. Typically, students must be presenting data at a conference in order to be eligible for financial support. In addition, many professional societies (who organize conferences) set aside competitive funds for student travel.
ABOUT FINISHING UP
What is the normal length of time required to complete my degree?
The expected times-to-completion are 2 yrs for the MSc and 4 yrs for the PhD degree.
Will I get paid if I go overtime?
Students who are overtime need to consult with their supervisors about the possibility for continued funding after the date for the minimum guaranteed stipend has passed.
When and how do I apply for an extension if I go over the time limits?
Students need to apply to the School of Graduate Studies (SGS) for time limit extensions. A one-semester extension is usually accommodated without an issue. Thereafter, more documentation and rationale for the extension may be requested by SGS.
Who should be a co-author on papers that come out of my thesis work?
See Section 13.3 in the Department Guide to Grad Studies (http://www.queensu.ca/biology/gradpostdoc/current/guide-2.html)
There should be a separate section (1-2 pages), following the Abstract of your thesis, in which you outline who the co-authors (if there were any) are for each of the chapters and what their contribution was. You should also make it very clear here what your contribution was to each co-authored chapter. If there were no co-authors, do not include this section. In many cases, students will indicate in this section, which figures (tables, etc), or part-thereof, were generated by co-authors. In cases were data presented in a thesis is from an Honour’s student who was mentored by the graduate student, this can also be indicated in this ‘Coauthorship’ section.
When can I publish my thesis?
Publications (journal articles) arising from a thesis are often published (or submitted for publication) before the thesis has been defended.
Can my supervisor (or anyone else) publish data that I collected for my thesis?
Supervisors have the right to write up and take first authorship on papers based on any material in the thesis or arising from the thesis that is not submitted for publication within one year of normal degree time limits (2 years for MSc, 4 for PhD). Since the student will be co-author on such papers, such thesis material may be used directly without infringing on the student's copyright. See Section 6 in the Department Guide to Grad Studies (http://www.queensu.ca/biology/gradpostdoc/current/guide-2.html)